Back to blog
Risk ManagementLogatrade6 June 20266 min read

Risk to Reward Ratios: Why 1:2 Isn't Automatically Better Than 1:1

One of the most pervasive myths in retail trading is that you must maintain a minimum risk-to-reward ratio of 1:2 or 1:3 to be profitable. Beginners are routinely instructed to discard any setup that does not offer double or triple the potential gain relative to the stop loss.

This dogmatic focus on high risk-to-reward ratios ignores a fundamental law of trading probability: win rate and risk-to-reward ratio are inversely linked. As you expand your target distance relative to your stop loss, your statistical win rate naturally declines.

A rigid insistence on 1:2 or 1:3 targets often causes traders to reject highly profitable 1:1 systems in favour of low win-rate strategies that trigger severe emotional stress and long losing streaks. Here is why 1:2 is not automatically superior to 1:1, and how to find the optimal balance for your strategy.

The dogmatic trap of high risk-to-reward ratios

The appeal of a high risk-to-reward ratio is obvious. If you achieve a 1:3 risk-to-reward ratio on every trade, you can lose 70% of your setups and still remain profitable.

However, financial markets do not deliver wide profit targets on demand. Price must travel through liquidity zones, structural support and resistance, and daily volatility limits to reach a 1:3 target. The further away your take-profit target is placed relative to your stop loss, the higher the probability that price reverses before reaching it.

"A 1:3 risk-to-reward setup on paper is completely useless if market structure prevents price from reaching the target 80% of the time."

Traders who force high risk-to-reward ratios on charts often watch trades move into substantial profit, only to reverse and hit their stop loss because they refused to take a 1:1 gain.

The mathematical connection between win rate and R:R

Win rate and risk-to-reward ratio exist on a mathematical continuum. To determine whether a strategy makes money, you must evaluate both variables together using the breakeven win rate formula:

Breakeven Win Rate = 1 / (1 + Risk-to-Reward Ratio)

Let us examine the breakeven requirements across common risk-to-reward profiles:

  • 1:0.5 R:R -> Requires a 66.67% win rate to break even.
  • 1:1.0 R:R -> Requires a 50.00% win rate to break even.
  • 1:1.5 R:R -> Requires a 40.00% win rate to break even.
  • 1:2.0 R:R -> Requires a 33.33% win rate to break even.
  • 1:3.0 R:R -> Requires a 25.00% win rate to break even.

A strategy with a 1:1 risk-to-reward ratio requires only a 51% win rate to generate positive net profit. If a trader can achieve a 60% win rate taking high-probability 1:1 setups, their equity curve will grow steadily with low drawdowns.

Comparing expectancy: 1:1 vs 1:2 vs 1:3

To prove why 1:2 is not inherently superior, let us compare the mathematical expectancy of three distinct trading strategies over a sample size of 100 executed trades, assuming a fixed risk of £100 per trade.

Formula for Expectancy:

Expectancy per Trade = (Win Rate × Average Win) - (Loss Rate × Average Loss)

Strategy A: High Win-Rate 1:1 System

  • Risk: £100 | Target Win: £100 (1:1 R:R)
  • Win Rate: 60% (60 wins) | Loss Rate: 40% (40 losses)
  • Expectancy = (0.60 × £100) - (0.40 × £100) = £60 - £40 = +£20 per trade.
  • Total Return over 100 trades = 100 × £20 = +£2,000 net profit.

Strategy B: Standard 1:2 System

  • Risk: £100 | Target Win: £200 (1:2 R:R)
  • Win Rate: 35% (35 wins) | Loss Rate: 65% (65 losses)
  • Expectancy = (0.35 × £200) - (0.65 × £100) = £70 - £65 = +£5 per trade.
  • Total Return over 100 trades = 100 × £5 = +£500 net profit.

Strategy C: Forced 1:3 System

  • Risk: £100 | Target Win: £300 (1:3 R:R)
  • Win Rate: 20% (20 wins) | Loss Rate: 80% (80 losses)
  • Expectancy = (0.20 × £300) - (0.80 × £100) = £60 - £80 = -£20 per trade.
  • Total Return over 100 trades = 100 × (-£20) = -£2,000 net loss.

In this scenario, Strategy A (1:1 R:R) generates four times the net profit of Strategy B (1:2 R:R), while Strategy C (1:3 R:R) loses money because the market conditions could not support a 20% win rate at that wide target distance.

The psychological reality of low win-rate strategies

Beyond raw mathematical expectancy, traders must account for execution psychology. Low win-rate strategies with high risk-to-reward ratios expose traders to severe losing streaks that test mental endurance.

Consider the probability of encountering five consecutive losing trades under different win-rate profiles:

At a 60% Win Rate (Strategy A, 1:1 R:R): Probability of 5 consecutive losses = (0.40)^5 = 1.02% (approx 1 in 98 trade sequences). At a 20% Win Rate (Strategy C, 1:3 R:R): Probability of 5 consecutive losses = (0.80)^5 = 32.77% (approx 1 in 3 trade sequences).

A trader utilizing a 1:3 system will routinely encounter strings of 5 to 10 consecutive losses. During these drawdowns, psychological fatigue, self-doubt, and revenge trading frequently lead to abandoned rules, missed winning trades, or blown accounts.

Conversely, a 1:1 system with a 60% win rate delivers frequent positive feedback, producing a smoother equity curve that is significantly easier to execute consistently.

How to find your system's ideal R:R balance

Rather than forcing an arbitrary 1:2 or 1:3 target on every trade setup, follow this process to determine your system's optimal target profile:

  1. Audit historical price movement: Measure how far price realistically moves after hitting your entry triggers before experiencing a major pullback.
  2. Test multiple target exits: Calculate your historical win rate at 1:1, 1:1.5, and 1:2 target levels.
  3. Compute expected value for each tier: Identify which target distance yields the highest net mathematical expectancy.
  4. Factor in execution stress: Choose the target model that maximises return while maintaining a win rate high enough to prevent psychological burnout.

Discovering your optimal R:R ratio with Logatrade

Determining whether your setup works better at 1:1 or 1:2 requires tracking actual market execution rather than relying on backtest assumptions. Logatrade automatically tracks your realized risk-to-reward ratios alongside trade win rates, categorizing performance by setup tag. By analyzing your performance data in Logatrade, you can instantly see whether taking quick 1:1 profits yields higher net returns than holding for 1:2 targets, helping you tailor your trade exit strategy around real empirical data.

The bottom line

A 1:2 risk-to-reward ratio is not inherently better than 1:1; your profitability is defined by the mathematical product of win rate and reward distance. High win-rate 1:1 strategies often yield smoother equity growth and lower execution stress than low win-rate 1:3 models. Stop forcing arbitrary targets on your charts, measure your strategy's true expectancy, and execute the ratio that aligns with your edge.

Find the mistake you keep repeating

Take the free 7-day audit and see exactly which behaviour is costing you money.

Start the free 7-day audit

More in Risk Management

© 2026 Logatrade. A journalling and performance review tool. Not financial advice. Trading involves risk. Logatrade is an independent trading journal and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any prop firm or broker mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners. Firm rules are provided as a guide; always confirm current rules with your firm.

Your privacy choices

We always use the storage needed to keep you signed in and the site secure. With your permission we also use anonymous page-view analytics and load third-party charts from TradingView. You can change this any time from "Cookie settings" in the footer. Read more